Data breaches, phishing scams, and stolen mail can put your personal information in the wrong hands. Two free tools can stop someone from opening new credit in your name: the credit freeze and the fraud alert. They work differently, and many people benefit from using one or both.
This guide compares them and walks you through placing and lifting each.
Key Takeaways
- A credit freeze restricts access to your credit report, making it very difficult to open new credit in your name. It is free.
- A fraud alert asks businesses to take extra steps to verify your identity before extending credit. It is also free.
- You must place a freeze separately at each bureau; a fraud alert placed at one bureau is shared with the other two.
- Neither affects your credit score or your existing accounts.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Credit freeze | Initial fraud alert | Extended fraud alert |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free | Free | Free |
| How it works | Blocks most access to your report | Requires businesses to take reasonable steps to verify identity | Requires stronger verification, often contacting you |
| Duration | Until you lift it | 1 year (renewable) | 7 years |
| Who can request | Anyone | Anyone who suspects fraud | Identity theft victims with an identity theft report |
| Contact all three bureaus? | Yes, separately | No, one bureau notifies the others | No, one bureau notifies the others |
| Affects credit score? | No | No | No |
| Extra benefit | Strongest protection against new accounts | Easy, quick | Removes you from prescreened offers for 5 years; extra free reports |

How to Place a Credit Freeze
- Contact Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion separately, online, by phone, or by mail.
- Verify your identity.
- Save the PIN, password, or account login each bureau provides; you will need it to lift the freeze.
- Confirm the freeze is in place.
By law, bureaus must place a freeze within one business day of an online or phone request, and within three business days of a mail request.
How to Lift a Freeze
When you apply for credit, you can lift the freeze temporarily (for a set period or for a specific lender) or permanently. Online and phone requests to lift must be completed within one hour; mail requests within three business days. Ask the lender which bureau it uses so you can lift only that one.
How to Place a Fraud Alert
- Contact any one of the three bureaus.
- Request an initial fraud alert (or an extended alert with an identity theft report).
- The bureau notifies the other two.
- Make sure your phone number is current so businesses can contact you.
Which Should You Choose?
| Situation | Recommended |
|---|---|
| Your data was exposed in a breach | Credit freeze (and optionally a fraud alert) |
| You are a confirmed identity theft victim | Extended fraud alert and credit freeze |
| You apply for credit often and want lighter protection | Fraud alert |
| You want maximum protection and rarely apply for credit | Credit freeze |
| You are an active-duty service member | Active duty alert, plus consider a freeze |
Other Freezes Worth Considering
- ChexSystems, used by banks to screen new checking accounts
- National Consumer Telecom and Utilities Exchange (NCTUE), used by some phone and utility companies
- Employment and tenant screening companies in some cases
These can help prevent fraudulent bank, phone, or utility accounts.
What a Freeze Does Not Do
- It does not stop fraud on existing accounts; monitor statements
- It does not prevent tax or medical identity theft
- It does not remove fraudulent accounts already on your report; use the identity theft dispute kit
- It does not block access by your existing creditors, debt collectors, or government agencies for certain purposes
Freeze Record Sheet
CREDIT FREEZE RECORD
Equifax – Date frozen: ______ PIN/login stored at: ____________
Experian – Date frozen: ______ PIN/login stored at: ____________
TransUnion – Date frozen: ______ PIN/login stored at: ____________
ChexSystems (optional) – Date frozen: ______
NCTUE (optional) – Date frozen: ______
Temporary lifts:
Date: ______ Bureau: ______ Reason: ______________ Re-freeze date: ______
Date: ______ Bureau: ______ Reason: ______________ Re-freeze date: ______
Store PINs and logins securely, not on the same paper as your Social Security number.
Example: Breach Response in 20 Minutes
A hypothetical consumer receives a notice that her information was exposed in a data breach at a healthcare company. She spends 20 minutes freezing her credit online at all three bureaus, records her logins in her password manager, and places a one-year fraud alert.
Six months later, someone tries to open a credit card in her name. The application fails because the issuer cannot access her frozen report. She keeps checking her free weekly credit reports and sees no new accounts.
Where This Guide Fits in Your Workflow
- Before: Check your free weekly credit reports for accounts you do not recognize.
- Alongside: If you find fraud, start the identity theft dispute kit.
- After: Store freeze PINs securely and record temporary lifts in your document system.
Quick-Use Checklist
- ☐ Freeze placed at Equifax
- ☐ Freeze placed at Experian
- ☐ Freeze placed at TransUnion
- ☐ Optional freezes considered (ChexSystems, NCTUE)
- ☐ Fraud alert added if fraud is suspected
- ☐ PINs and logins stored securely
Frequently Asked Questions
No. A freeze does not affect your score.
Yes. Existing accounts are unaffected.
No. Collectors and existing creditors can still access your report for permitted purposes.
Parents can request a protected record or freeze for children under 16 at each bureau, which can prevent child identity theft. For more on dealing with fraudulent debts, read debt from identity theft .
Lock It Down
Debt Remediation Tools from Foxboro Consulting Group, Inc. includes this freeze record sheet, a fraud alert checklist, and identity theft dispute templates.
Worried about a data breach? Freeze your credit at all three bureaus today; it is free.
Disclaimer: Templates and tools in this article are provided for general educational purposes and are not legal advice. Adapt every letter to your own facts, keep copies of everything you send, and consult a licensed attorney in your state before responding to a lawsuit or court deadline.